The Gambia v. Myanmar

Last week, I was fortunate enough to be able to take a trip to The Hague to follow the legal case brought against Myanmar by The Gambia. I was luckier still to get one of the tickets to watch the case inside, after waiting in the cold from 5am. The case regards the genocide in Rakhine state against the minority Rohingya population. ‘Genocide’ is referred to as the crime of crimes, and it is a crime the authorities in Myanmar have continuously denied. The evidence is quite overwhelming, and the Gambia made a concrete and compelling case at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) last week. The stories from survivors are horrific, including instances of gang rape, children being thrown into fires, and homes set ablaze. State Counsellor Aung San Suu Kyi, Myanmar’s de-facto leader who shares power with the military in a quasi-civilian democratic state, travelled to The Hague to personally defend Myanmar against allegations of genocide. The world’s eyes were once again on the Nobel Laurette democracy icon whose struggle in the 1990s against the military brought her international fame. She stood in the courtroom with a certain grace reminiscent of her past. But the lady before the court was a lot different to the lady that the international community once loved. There she spoke and denied allegations of genocide. She acknowledged that there may have been a disproportionate response from the ‘Tatmadaw’ following attacks on police border posts by the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA), but she stood by the clearance operations as legitimate counter-terrorism efforts. She also pleaded that the court leave Myanmar to Myanmar and reject the provisional measures requested by The Gambia. Many in Myanmar support their leader, Aung San Suu Kyi. Which makes me sad, as this not about Aung San Suu Kyi. This is about human beings. How human beings perceive themselves and others, and whether they view other humans as worthy of the same rights that they perceive themselves to deserve. Myanmar has been a country and a people that have taken my heart, their generosity and grace towards me is beyond any welcome I’ve ever seen. But there’s this dark side to a lot of them that they don’t want to make light. Not all of them of course, but many in Myanmar do treat the Rohingya as sub-human. They can’t see the dark, that hatred that festers towards another people. Can any of us really see the faults in ourselves, and how do we make sure we can always see those faults so we can change, to perfect ourselves. I think values and principles offer us the best safeguard. If we understand that we ourselves are worthy of human rights because we understand our identity as human beings, then we can respect the human rights of those different to us because we still see them as human beings. When our identity gets caught up on ethnicities, nationalities, or race, that’s when we start to calculate who is worth more than who. When we realise that by denying another ethnicity their human rights, we in affect allow other ethnicities to make the same error of judgment and deny ours because of our ethnicity. When the method for determining who gets what rights because of certain differences becomes stand practice, that’s when we undermine our own human rights and the rights of others. It is either all human beings get human rights, or none get human rights, there is no justification of anywhere in between. For the sake of our human rights then, to best protect them we have to stand up and protect the rights of others. An attack on human rights is an attack on us all, for are we not all human. And one day I hope that many in Myanmar who see the Rohingya as their enemy, will see them as human. Hopefully this case will get the Rohingya some measure of justice, however small. We’re expecting the court to rule on the provisional measures requested by The Gambia next month to help safeguard the Rohingya still remaining in Rakhine. Unfortunately, the international community seems to be losing its grit in dealing with human rights, as human rights violations are becoming standard practice around the world. Here in the UK, the new government is expected to amend the Human Rights Act, the days are getting darker. What light that remains for peace, justice and a dignified human existence shines from the United Nations, the NGOs and charities working tirelessly for the humanitarian cause, in a world where money is of more worth than the human being. That light is worth fighting for.

Young Activists Summit 2019 – UN Office at Geneva.

The Young Activists Summit in The Human Rights and Alliance of Civilisations Room at the United Nations Office in Geneva. Happy Human Rights Day too! 10th December

On the 10th of December I was lucky enough to get back to the United Nations Office in Geneva for the Young Activists Summit. It was the first Young Activists Summit and its first year started with an inspiring panel of changemakers. I think we’ve all been there, wanting to make a difference, a notable one. Is there really anything more valuable than to fight for a cause that benefits others. I guess that depends on whether you consider benefiting others a valuable pursuit, when you could always benefit yourself. But then what are you left with? An empty achievement that can only be shared by oneself. I think the human race needs a talk. A serious talk about economics and evolving our livelihoods around the 9-5s. Does it make us happy? Not according to the research on anxiety and depression, which are higher in the West. The simple truth is there’s nothing that comes close to living for love. It is the purest emotion that human beings are capable of, and nothing should be placed above it. The six activists on the panel today had a clear love and devotion for their causes. That’s what makes their passions so pure. Whatever their hurdles, whether it was rape or imprisonment, their love grew ad grew and they became at one with what they were fighting for. To attach yourself to a cause that gets your every piece of mind sounds like a remarkable achievement in itself. We all have value to bring, but knowing exactly what that value is, that’s where it gets tricky and we don’t know what we can bring to the table. One of the first things you should look to identify is what positive effect do you have on others. It’s a useful starting point, if you help those around you instill confidence than that can highlight your character’s ability for leadership for etc. There’s so many ways we can benefit one another, and just imagine the world we could live in if everyone lived to benefit one another. The world would be so pure. A world where there was no malice or bad intentions towards one another. Impossible says many, it’s human nature. I disagree, I can give you loads of examples of human beings who are non-violent, they worked on themselves, and they found a purer way to live, using love and compassion as their compasses, not hate and anger. Dare to dream, as these activists did, and their struggles and achievements shall be documented below.

Nadia Murad, 26 Years Old, Nobel Peace Prize Winner 2018, Iraq

Nadia Murad was 21 at the time when ISIS abducted, raped and enslaved her among thousands other Yazidi women. Fortunately, she managed to escape and she told her story to the world, leading a campaign to draw the attention of governments to the plight of Yazidi women. She’s never stopped fighting. She was the shared co-recipient of the 2018 Nobel Peace Prize with Dr Denis Mukwege Mukengere, and has received numerous other awards recognising her work to benefit humanity and particularly those that have suffered from genocide and gender based violence. You can learn more about this incredible woman and her initiative here.

Amy & Ella Meek, 14 & 16 Years Old, United Kingdom

These two sisters are the founders of “Kids Against Plastic” a social campaign for young people that tackles plastic pollution. They’ve already inspired youth action that has seen 70,000 pieces of single-use plastic removed, and they’re aiming for 100,000. The two sisters mainly work with schools and businesses to promote sustainability, and are pursuing their “Plastic Clever Programme.” More than 50 cafes and restaurants and more than 470 schools have already joined this programme! It’s incredible how two young girls can make such a huge difference to the world. There’s so many problems out there to tackle, take your pick and find a new angle. More about Kids Against Plastic can be seen here.

Memory Banda, 23 Years Old, Malawi

Memory Banda has gained the international community’s attention for her work fighting to end early and forced child marriages. She was particularly moved to fight this issue after her sister was forced to marry at the age of 11. Her work has been so successful it has helped change the law in her country, raising the minimum legal age for marriage from 15 to 18 years. An outstanding victory for everything that is good and right in our world, where women and girls are not compelled to serve the needs of men. She has since established Foundation 4 Girls Leadership and helps empower other women and girls to become leaders and know their rights. You can see more about them here.

Hamangaí Patoxó, 22 Years Old, Brasil

Hamangaí is a passionate protector of the Amazon rainforest and her people. Her friends and neighbours have been killed by those who seek to use the rainforest for profiteering. But her fire remains unextinguished and she continues to stand resolute in face of criminal opposition wanting to profit from the rainforest’s destruction. She involves herself in reforestation programmes and educates indigenous communities about their rights. She is a national coordinator for Engajamundo and you can see more about their work in the Amazon here.

Rebecca Kabuo, 25 Years Old, Democratic Republic of the Congo

Rebecca Kabuo, one of my personal favourites from the panel if I can say that, is a Congolese activist working for LUCHA (Lutte pour le changement) that calls for the respect of human rights, and laws in the DRC. LUCHA focus on non-violence and pursuing a peaceful society by dialogue and support for communities. She was imprisoned for her efforts, and was described on social networks as the youngest prisoner of conscious in the world. Because of her work, people see peace as a viable alternative to the conflict which has grown deep roots in the DRC. You can learn more about LUCHA here.

Those were the panel members today that we were all honoured to hear and learn from. The question that must always remain is what we can do. All of us. Mobilising towards the achievement of humanitarian efforts so we can build a dream world where peace is prevalent, and the rights of all are respected, with a stable environment so we don’t have to worry about the needs of future children.

Human Rights Violations Undermining Efforts for Peace

The Burmese Chinthe, a mythical lion-like creature that protects pagodas and riches, and will bring you good luck to increase those riches.

Whether it’s Myanmar, or outside in other corners of the world, one thing that always undermines the chances of a prosperous peace are human rights violations. When Governments, or militaries violate the rights of human beings, they perpetuate the notion that some peoples are ‘lower'(second-class), and some are ‘higher'(first-class). Such inequality between human beings will inevitably lead to conflict. Those that class themselves as ‘higher’, i.e. that their status is better, their characteristics are better etc., will feel the need to maintain that status by preying on those that are weaker. Those that can be deemed ‘lower’ in a society will suffer from the ‘higher’ who help maintain that human beings should be divided into a rankings based system, addressing an inferiority complex as they beat others down to feel superior. This does not create peace. Peace can only be achieved by harmonising groups that have previously been at a state of dissonance. Every time the central government in Myanmar commits human rights atrocities, it embeds further the dissonance between the groups it would eventually like to make peace with. If the central government are serious about national reconciliation they need to approach any conflict with the upmost respect for basic human rights. If there is a situation which requires the use of force, force is best carried out when it is restrained. In 2016 and 2017, when the violence broke out in Rakhine, there was no restraint. And now international legal challenges, negative economic impacts, and activist campaigns have brought down a damning hammer on Myanmar’s status on the world stage. What’s interesting is noting just how little has been done to repatriate the Rohingya and allow them to return with both the guarantees of citizenship and safety. When these events happen, they undermine trust significantly, and this distrust flows through the relationships of all parties to the conflict. Recommitting to respecting human rights is the first step towards resurfacing efforts for peace, but words can’t do it alone, action needs to be taken. Now around the world calls for justice are being made, and the International Criminal Court have moved further into their investigation. I often wonder if there’s any hope of justice for the victims or the ‘lower’ in Myanmar’s society, they do deserve it. Myanmar’s refusal to acknowledge wrongdoing will only make the situation worse, they need to start making concessions to blunt the worse impacts that these atrocities have cost them. Making a firm commitment to upholding human rights, and addressing the lack of respect around human rights, housed in the minds of the Burmese soldiers is a step in the right direction. But when doing wrong in this world, it is always best to start off with an apology.

Remembering Rakhine

Of my five trips to Myanmar, formerly known as Burma, I’ve been lucky enough to visit the infamous Rakhine State. It’s infamous because it is rife with troubles, genocide being the most visible trouble that has hurt its people dearly. What has happened in Rakhine has created global headlines in recent years, and the violence unfortunately hasn’t transformed into peace. The first time I visited I took a bus to Mrauk-U. Mrauk-U has a rich historical and cultural appeal, the old pagodas offer a glimpse into the old kingdom of Mrauk-U. But for me personally, it was far more interesting because it attracted very few tourists, and had only recently become a place for tourists to visit. Further still, it was situated in Rakhine State, and I was curious. Curious about the situation for the world’s most persecuted minority; the Rohingya. Rakhine, or Arakan State is the home of the Rohingya, although it’s a sorry state for a home. The Rohingya are regarded as stateless, they have no official citizenship, they are restricted from travel, voting, and even living. It has become a crime over recent decades to be born a member of this group in Myanmar. When I visited the archeological site in Mrauk U, across the paddy fields, and past the rolling hills on the horizon, I just remember smoke. I cannot say for certain what the smoke was, it could have been a deliberate fire to keep snakes and jungle critters away from crops, or it could have been something worse. Something that we know has happened in Rakhine. The Tatmadaw (Myanmar’s military) have burned down entire villages, raped women and girls, and put to slaughter innocent human beings just because their differences could be exploited to serve as a scapegoat for problems within the country. I’ll never know what it was that I saw, I hope it was just a farming technique, but I can’t ever escape from the possibility it wasn’t. That was in early 2017, and against, perhaps, my better judgement I decided to go further into Rakhine at the beginning of this year. The British Foreign Office Travel Advice recommended against all travel to Rakhine, there was now intense fighting between the Tatmadaw and an ethnic armed organisation; The Arakan Army. But I went anyway, I wanted to understand things properly, without the bias of the media, and a narrative that distorts truth. It was a long 24 hours on a bus to get there, frequent stops before we arrived at Rakhine’s capital city, Sittwe, offered a nice chance for me to compose my thoughts with a leaf wrapped cheroot cigar. It cleared my mind, I have taken risks abroad but not like this before. Not to a city surrounded by war, and entrenched in communal violence that has made international headlines. People ask me why I’ve taken risks like that, it’s not really a choice, for when is love ever really a choice. I feel like I have a sincere debt to Myanmar and its people, for the hospitality they’ve shown me throughout my travels. They’ve given me a reason to hope about the world, that they can suffer greatly, and yet still find meaning in this world to pursue, carrying on with the brightest of smiles. I hope I can work for them one day, as an international civil servant in the United Nations. When I finally arrived in Sittwe, 24 hours after setting off from Yangon, there was an uneasy tension. The people were carrying on with their daily lives, but you could never forget where you were, I’ve never seen so many soldiers. There I was, wondering around alone on the streets viewing the most fragile peace I’ve ever experienced in my life. Anything could break out at a moment’s notice, and I was actively searching up the regional headlines, seeing where the recent skirmishes had been reported. Along the main street was Sittwe’s main mosque, it was decaying. No one was allowed inside, road blocks and armed police guarded the mosque, and this had been the way for a while. Most of the Rohingya were already gone, ‘sheltered’ in a refugee camp in Bangladesh. While some remain, their situation remains fragile, anything could still happen, and the government still continues to be heartless. Which upon looking at the governments of the world seems to be endemic. It was impossible not to feel how powerless the compassionate were, at this moment in time, love is in ruins. I was out of Sittwe after only two days, best not to tempt fate. I was very lucky, there was a skirmish on the Yangon-Sittwe highway two days after my bus made the trip back to Yangon. Landmines went off on the same route within the space of two weeks after I left. I was lucky. What’s striking is that I was always met with the same compassion that I’d known all around Myanmar, it’s just a shame not all peoples are welcomed with it. I sincerely hope, that while some of the religious sites of the persecuted minorities in Myanmar are restricted, that they can still find their god, and their god will show them the love and the mercy they deserve, because they won’t get it from the government.